Scilly Butchers food hygiene rating
Retailers - other · Isles of Scilly
Scilly Butchers holds a 5, the highest food hygiene rating there is. At its last inspection the shop met every standard the inspector checked, with nothing needing attention.
The rating: 5 - Very good
The rating dates from 25 July 2025, 11 months ago. Councils typically re-inspect higher-risk businesses every six months to two years, with well-run, low-risk places visited least often, so this is a normal gap.
Address: Benney's Butchers, Garrison Lane, Hugh Town, TR21 0JD
How it compares in Isles of Scilly
That puts Scilly Butchers among the 91 places in Isles of Scilly holding top marks, 91% of everywhere the council rates. A 5 is the norm here rather than the exception, so it is the rating to expect, not to be impressed by.
| 5 out of 5 | 91 | 91% | ← Scilly Butchers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 out of 5 | 7 | 7% | ||
| 3 out of 5 | 2 | 2% | ||
| 2 out of 5 | 0 | 0% | ||
| 1 out of 5 | 0 | 0% | ||
| 0 out of 5 | 0 | 0% |
A further 31 businesses in the area are awaiting inspection or exempt, so are not counted above.
What the inspector found
- Hygienic food handling Good
- Cleanliness & condition of the building Good
- How well they manage food safety Good
An inspection scores three things: how food is handled, the physical condition of the premises, and how much the inspector trusts management to keep standards up. At Scilly Butchers none of the three raised a concern, the overall rating is only ever as strong as its weakest area, so a clean sweep is what produces a high score.
Food hygiene ratings nearby
The closest food businesses to Scilly Butchers, nearest first, so you can see how it compares to its neighbours.
| Business | Distance | Rating | Inspected |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hugh Street Cafe Retailers - other | 46 yards away | 5 - Very good | 20 June 2025 |
| Jacks Micro Bar Pub/bar/nightclub | 46 yards away | 5 - Very good | 22 April 2026 |
| Bishop And Wolf Other catering premises | 46 yards away | 5 - Very good | 22 September 2025 |
| Co-op Store Retailers - supermarkets/hypermarkets | 46 yards away | 5 - Very good | 19 March 2026 |
| Kavorna Cafe Restaurant/Cafe/Canteen | 46 yards away | 5 - Very good | 19 March 2026 |
| Tanglewood Kitchen Company Retailers - other | 46 yards away | 5 - Very good | 18 March 2026 |
| Wheelhouse Guest House Ltd Hotel/bed & breakfast/guest house | 63 yards away | 5 - Very good | 8 August 2023 |
| Sterren Gwyn - Vessel Farmers/growers | 64 yards away | Exempt |
Questions about Scilly Butchers
What is Scilly Butchers's food hygiene rating?
Scilly Butchers has a food hygiene rating of 5 out of 5 (very good), given by Isles of Scilly Council on 25 July 2025.
Is Scilly Butchers safe to eat at?
The rating covers hygiene standards found at inspection, not the food itself. At 5 out of 5, the inspector found hygiene standards at this shop to be very good, the top end of the scale.
When was Scilly Butchers last inspected?
Scilly Butchers was last inspected on 25 July 2025, 11 months ago. Food hygiene inspections are unannounced, and the rating is published by Isles of Scilly Council rather than by the business.
What did the inspector find at Scilly Butchers?
The inspector scored three areas. Hygienic food handling was rated "good", the cleanliness and condition of the building "good", and confidence in the management of food safety "good". Lower concern in all three is what earns a high overall rating.
How does Scilly Butchers compare to other places in Isles of Scilly?
91% of the 100 rated food businesses in Isles of Scilly hold the top rating of 5, and Scilly Butchers is one of them.
Who decides the rating?
Isles of Scilly Council inspects Scilly Butchers and sets the rating; the Food Standards Agency publishes it. Neither the business nor this site can change a rating, a business that disagrees can appeal to its council, and can request a re-inspection once it has fixed the problems.
Tell me when this changes
The Food Standards Agency publishes only a business's rating today, not what it scored before, and not when it moves. We check every UK rating each night. Watch Scilly Butchers and we will email you the morning after its rating changes.
Free, for three businesses, forever. No password, we send you a link. How rating alerts work →
Understanding this rating
More food hygiene ratings near here
Scilly Butchers is one of 80 rated food businesses in St Mary's. See every hygiene rating in St Mary's →
Isles of Scilly inspects and rates 131 food businesses across its whole area. See every food hygiene rating in Isles of Scilly →
The official record is held by the council: http://www.scilly.gov.uk/
Rating from the Food Standards Agency under the Open Government Licence. Ratings reflect standards found at the time of inspection and can change. If you think a rating is wrong, the official record is held by the FSA and the local authority; corrections there flow through here. How ratings work →